TL;DR
Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Guillermo Rodriguez and professional partner Witney Carson were eliminated from Dancing with the Stars after the show’s Tuesday Super Bowl-themed episode. On Jimmy Kimmel Live, Kimmel challenged the result, pointing to their online support and jokingly criticizing voters; the remarks were part of a comic reaction, not evidence of a voting irregularity.
Jimmy Kimmel criticized the outcome of Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson’s elimination from Dancing with the Stars, arguing on Jimmy Kimmel Live that the pair had strong online support but did not receive enough viewer votes to stay. The comic reaction followed Tuesday’s Super Bowl-themed Week 5 episode, where their salsa earned 22 out of 40 from the judges.
Kimmel pointed to YouTube numbers as evidence that Guillermo and Carson had attracted attention. He said their performance clips from the previous week had received more than three times as many views as those of the next-ranked pair he cited. A chart shown on the program put Guillermo and Carson at 719,000 views, compared with 231,000 for Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson. Those figures measure views, not votes, and do not establish how viewers voted.
The elimination episode featured Guillermo and Carson dancing a salsa to a Bad Bunny song. The judges gave them a combined 22 points out of 40: Carrie Ann Inaba and Joe Buck each awarded six, while Derek Hough and Bruno Tonioli each gave five. Kimmel called the routine an “11 out of 10” in his own book, then mocked the panel by referring to the judges as “radical, left wing.” That characterization was a joke from Kimmel, not a factual description of the judges.
After the results, Kimmel spoke live with Guillermo and Carson backstage. When he asked whether they would accept the outcome or take legal action, Guillermo replied that he thought they should take legal action, and Carson agreed. The exchange was presented as banter; no actual legal action was announced. Carson praised Guillermo as a “sweetheart” and joked that Kimmel could now take him back. Guillermo said he had set out to lose weight and had done so.
Late-night reaction · Week 5 recap
Why Is Jimmy Kimmel Criticizing Voters After Guillermo’s ‘DWTS’ Elimination?
After Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson left Dancing with the Stars, Kimmel questioned the result on his show. His case leaned on online attention—and came with a comic caveat: views are not votes.
At a glance
What happened on the show
The elimination-night salsa
The comparison Kimmel cited
YouTube views shown in a chart on Jimmy Kimmel Live. Counts are not voting totals.
Why the result drew attention
Online support is not the same as votes
Views signal reach
Kimmel said the pair’s clips from the previous week had more than three times the views of the next-ranked pair he cited.
Watching is not voting
A video view does not show whether someone voted, how often they voted, or which contestants received their votes.
The vote details are private
The available recap does not give vote totals, margins, or the complete standings needed to explain the elimination.
The online comparison cannot verify the outcome
Kimmel framed the result as surprising for fans who followed the clips. The figures alone do not establish why the pair went home or whether judges’ scores or audience votes were decisive.
The five-week run
From familiar sidekick to dance-floor favorite
Guillermo Rodriguez, a longtime presence on Jimmy Kimmel Live, competed with professional dancer Witney Carson. Kimmel openly backed the duo, making their Week 5 exit a personal late-night talking point.
Competition
Guillermo and Witney pair up for the season.
Viewer support
Kimmel encourages viewers to support the pair.
Super Bowl week
The duo performs a salsa to a Bad Bunny song.
Results
The judges award 22 points out of 40; the pair is eliminated.
Late-night response
Kimmel questions the result and jokes about the judges.
“In my book, that was an 11 out of 10.”
Jimmy Kimmel on the routine“Radical, left wing.”
Kimmel’s joking description of the judges“I think we should take legal action.”
Guillermo Rodriguez, backstage“He’s such a sweetheart. He’s so loved by everyone.”
Witney Carson on GuillermoThe backstage exchange about legal action was presented as banter. No lawsuit, filing, or formal challenge was reported. Kimmel’s description of the judges was also a joke, not a factual characterization.
Quick answers
What we know—and what remains unknown
Why did Jimmy Kimmel criticize voters?
He questioned why viewers did not keep Guillermo and Witney in the competition, pointing to high YouTube views. His comments were a humorous defense of his colleague.
Did the YouTube views prove they should advance?
No. The figures measure video views, not votes, and do not show how viewers voted or how the pair’s vote total compared with others.
How did their final dance score?
Their salsa earned 22 out of 40: two judges awarded six points, and two awarded five.
Are Guillermo and Witney taking legal action?
No legal action was reported. Their agreement with Kimmel’s joking suggestion was part of a comedic backstage exchange.
Reported as the following week’s theme.
Dancing with the Stars airs Tuesday nights at 8 p.m. Eastern and Pacific, according to the recap.
Episodes are available the following day, per the reported schedule.
Why Online Support Was Not Enough
The moment highlights the difference between social-media attention and competition votes. Kimmel’s comparison made the elimination appear surprising to fans who saw the high view count as evidence of a strong following. But video views do not show how many unique people watched, whether they voted, or how their votes were distributed.
The result also underscores the role of the show’s audience in determining who continues. Kimmel said Guillermo had been in the bottom two before and had depended on viewer votes to advance. The episode’s outcome became a late-night talking point because Rodriguez is a familiar presence on Kimmel’s program, and the host had openly supported his run on the dance competition. His criticism was framed as a humorous defense of a colleague, rather than a documented challenge to the result.
Dancing with the Stars salsa dance costume
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Guillermo’s Five-Week DWTS Run
Rodriguez, known as a longtime sidekick on Jimmy Kimmel Live, competed on Dancing with the Stars with professional dancer Witney Carson. The pair reached Week 5 before leaving the competition. Kimmel had encouraged viewers to support them and described the duo as a favorite among online audiences.
The elimination came during a Super Bowl-themed installment, with the pair performing a salsa. Kimmel’s show replayed the judges’ scores and footage of television coverage from across the United States and Canada that had backed Guillermo. The episode recap reported that Dancing with the Stars airs on ABC and Disney+ on Tuesday nights at 8 p.m. Eastern and Pacific time, with episodes available on Hulu the following day.
“Last week, Guillermo and Witney had more than triple the YouTube views of their closest opponent.”
— Jimmy Kimmel
What the View Counts Cannot Show
The reported YouTube totals do not reveal the number of votes cast for each pair, the voting margin, or whether viewers who watched clips also voted. The available details do not establish why Guillermo and Carson were eliminated or whether their judges’ score or audience vote was decisive. Kimmel’s criticism was a reaction to the result, and the exchange about legal action was comedic; there is no reported filing or formal dispute.
The recap also does not provide a full account of the voting rules or the complete episode standings. Without those details, the online-view comparison cannot be used to confirm or disprove the legitimacy of the elimination.
Dedication Night Follows the Exit
Dancing with the Stars is scheduled to continue with Dedication Night in the following week’s episode, according to the episode information reported in the recap. Guillermo and Carson are out of the competition, while Kimmel’s comments add a separate late-night reaction to the result. No further action by the pair was reported.
The next episode will show which remaining contestants advance. The voting figures behind this elimination have not been made public in the information available, so whether online enthusiasm translated into votes remains unknown.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
Key Questions
Why did Jimmy Kimmel criticize Dancing with the Stars voters?
Kimmel questioned why viewers did not keep Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson in the competition, especially after citing high YouTube views for their recent performances. He made the comments as a humorous defense of his colleague.
How did Guillermo and Witney’s final dance score?
Their salsa received 22 out of 40 from the judges: two sixes and two fives.
Did the YouTube views prove they should have advanced?
No. The figures Kimmel showed were video-view counts, not votes. They do not establish how many people voted for the pair or how the audience vote compared with other contestants.
Are Guillermo and Witney taking legal action?
No legal action was reported. Guillermo and Carson agreed when Kimmel jokingly raised the possibility, but the exchange was presented as banter.
What is the next Dancing with the Stars theme?
The following week’s theme was reported as Dedication Night. The show airs Tuesday nights on ABC and Disney+, with the episode available on Hulu the next day.
Source: Yahoo Entertainment
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
