Choosing the best eye highlighter depends heavily on your needs—whether you want a subtle glow, a quick highlighting stick, or a multi-use shimmery product. My top picks include the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Baked Gelato Swirl Illuminator for a natural, luminous finish suitable for all skin tones, and the Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener for versatile, long-lasting glow with a creamy texture. The tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight stands out for its waterproof, all-day performance, ideal for busy days or contact lens wearers. Each option trades off certain qualities, like ease of blending or shade variety, to better fit different preferences and routines. This guide will help you navigate those differences to find the perfect eye highlighter for your style and needs.
Get the latest gadgets delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The LAURA GELLER Baked Gelato Swirl offers a natural, long-lasting glow for all skin tones.
- The Lune+Aster Pencil delivers effortless, precise highlighting in a convenient, vegan stick format.
- tarte Fake Awake provides waterproof, brightening power suitable for all-day wear and sensitive eyes.
- Thrive Causemetics Stick adds multi-use shimmer with nourishing ingredients, but may demand extra blending.
- Choosing the right highlighter depends on your preference for texture, longevity, and application style.
| LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Baked Gelato Swirl Illuminator, Gilded Honey |  | Best for a natural, luminous glow | Type: Baked gelato swirl illuminator | Finish: Natural glow | Suitable for: All skin tones | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Lune+Aster Eye Illuminator Highlighter Pencil Crayon, Silky Champagne |  | Best for precise, effortless highlighting | Shade: Champagne | Format: Crayon stick | Texture: Silky | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight – Brightening Highlighter Pencil for Eyes & Brows |  | Best for all-day waterproof brightening | Type: Highlighter pencil | Vegan: Yes | Cruelty-Free: Yes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener Eyeshadow Stick Champagne Shine |  | Best for multi-use, nourishing glow | Finish: Shimmer | Formulation: Cream-to-powder | Waterproof: Yes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| eye highlighter | Type | Finish | Application | Texture |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Baked Ge | Baked gelato swirl illuminator | Natural glow | Melts into skin | Creamy gel |
| Lune+Aster Eye Illuminator Hig | — | — | — | Silky |
| tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight | Highlighter pencil | — | Smooth with smudger | — |
| Thrive Causemetics Brilliant E | — | Shimmer | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Baked Gelato Swirl Illuminator, Gilded Honey
This baked gelato swirl illuminator stands out for its ability to produce a radiant, lit-from-within look without any glitter or shimmer. It melts seamlessly into the skin, making it suitable for all skin tones, and offers impressive longevity. Compared with powder highlighters, this gelato formula provides a more natural, dewy finish that enhances high points without looking obvious. Its main tradeoff is that it requires proper application—pressing or tapping into the skin to avoid unevenness—making it less ideal for quick, casual use.
Pros:- Creates a natural, luminous glow
- Suitable for all skin tones
- Long-lasting, melts into skin
Cons:- Requires proper application for best results
Best for: Those seeking a natural, dewy glow that can suit any skin tone and prefer a melt-in formula
Not ideal for: Users who want a quick, powder finish or prefer high shimmer effects
- Type:Baked gelato swirl illuminator
- Finish:Natural glow
- Suitable for:All skin tones
- Longevity:Long-lasting
- Application:Melts into skin
- Texture:Creamy gel
Our verdict“This pick is ideal for anyone wanting a subtle, skin-like glow with long-lasting performance.”
Lune+Aster Eye Illuminator Highlighter Pencil Crayon, Silky Champagne
The Lune+Aster Eye Illuminator in Champagne offers a quick, fuss-free way to add radiance. Its silky crayon format makes application straightforward, especially for targeted areas like the inner corners or brow bone. Being vegan, gluten-free, and dermatologist tested, it appeals to those with sensitive skin or who prefer clean beauty. Its main advantage over powders is the ease of use, but the limited shade options and the fact that it’s a stick highlighter mean it might not satisfy those seeking more vibrant or varied finishes. For minimal effort, this is a reliable choice.
Pros:- Creates effortlessly illuminated eyes
- Convenient crayon stick format
- Vegan, gluten-free, dermatologist tested
Cons:- Limited shade options
- May not suit those seeking powder highlighters
Best for: People wanting a quick, precise highlight without the mess of powders
Not ideal for: Users who prefer powder textures or multiple shades
- Shade:Champagne
- Format:Crayon stick
- Texture:Silky
- Vegan:Yes
- Gluten-Free:Yes
- Dermatologist Tested:Yes
- Paraben-Free:Yes
Our verdict“Perfect for users who prioritize ease and precision in their highlighting routine.”
tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight – Brightening Highlighter Pencil for Eyes & Brows
The tarte Fake Awake Highlighter is designed for a long-lasting, waterproof glow that brightens multiple eye areas, including the inner corners, brow bone, and waterline. Its smooth application with a built-in smudger makes it easy to use, and its vegan, cruelty-free formula is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. While it provides impressive durability, it might require multiple layers for an intense brightness, and the shade range appears limited to a single highlight shade. It’s an excellent choice for those needing all-day, fuss-free brightness that stays put through sweat or tears.
Pros:- Long-lasting, waterproof formula
- Vegan and cruelty-free
- Smooth application with built-in smudger
- Brightens multiple eye areas
Cons:- May require multiple layers for brightness
- Limited shade options
Best for: Anyone needing a durable, waterproof highlighter for busy or active days
Not ideal for: Users who prefer shimmer or multiple shades for variety
- Type:Highlighter pencil
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
- Waterproof:Yes
- Duration:8 hours
- Application:Smooth with smudger
Our verdict“This highlighter is perfect for anyone who needs reliable, waterproof brightness that lasts all day.”
Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener Eyeshadow Stick Champagne Shine
The Thrive Causemetics Brightening Eye Stick combines the ease of a stick with a versatile cream-to-powder finish. Its shimmering Champagne Shine adds a soft, diffused glow that works well on the eyes, brow bone, or even cheekbones for a subtle radiance. Enriched with nourishing oils like macadamia seed and meadowfoam seed, it offers hydration and crease resistance. However, the need to sharpen the product can be inconvenient, and blending might be tricky for some users. This pick makes the most sense for those who want a multi-purpose, nourishing product that can double as a subtle highlighter or eyeshadow.
Pros:- Long-lasting, waterproof formula
- Multi-use for eyes, cheeks, and lips
- Infused with nourishing oils
- Crease-resistant
Cons:- Requires sharpening
- Limited to shimmer finish in this shade
Best for: Users seeking a multi-use, nourishing glow with a creamy texture
Not ideal for: People who prefer shimmer-free or matte finishes or dislike sharpening
- Finish:Shimmer
- Formulation:Cream-to-powder
- Waterproof:Yes
- Nourishing Ingredients:Macadamia seed oil, Meadowfoam seed oil
- Built-in Sharpener:Yes
- Usage:Eyes, brow, cheekbones, lips
Our verdict“This multi-use stick is a great choice for those who want a nourishing, versatile highlighter with a gentle glow.”
How We Picked
Our selection process focused on highlighters that excel in eye illumination, balancing factors like application ease, longevity, finish, and versatility. I prioritized products that offer clear differentiation—whether through texture, format, or special features—so each pick serves a distinct user need. We evaluated user reviews, brand reputation, ingredient quality, and performance reports to identify options suitable for a range of preferences, from quick touch-ups to more detailed highlighting. Tradeoffs, such as limited shades or need for sharpening, were considered to clarify who each product benefits most.
| eye highlighter | Type | Finish | Application | Texture |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Baked Ge | Baked gelato swirl illuminator | Natural glow | Melts into skin | Creamy gel |
| Lune+Aster Eye Illuminator Hig | — | — | — | Silky |
| tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight | Highlighter pencil | — | Smooth with smudger | — |
| Thrive Causemetics Brilliant E | — | Shimmer | — | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Eye Highlighters
Choosing the best eye highlighter involves considering your preferred application style, finish, longevity, and whether you want a product suitable for various uses or a dedicated highlight. The right highlighter should seamlessly enhance your features without feeling heavy or obvious, and the format—whether cream, pencil, or gel—should match your routine. Understanding these factors helps narrow down choices and ensures you select a product that enhances your natural beauty effortlessly.Application Style
Decide whether you prefer a quick swipe with a stick, a precise pencil for targeted highlighting, or a more nuanced gel or cream. Stick highlighters like the Thrive Causemetics offer multi-use convenience, while pencils such as the tarte Fake Awake excel for pinpoint brightening. Gels or creams like the Laura Geller provide a more natural, skin-like glow when you want a subtle effect. Your routine and comfort with blending will guide this choice.
Finish and Effect
Consider whether you want a luminous, satin, or shimmer finish. For a soft, natural glow, the Laura Geller baked gelato is ideal. If you desire a more vibrant or reflective shine, the Thrive Causemetics stick provides a subtle shimmer. For brightening the inner corners and waterline, the waterproof options like tarte Fake Awake deliver durability and brightness, but may lack the shimmer of other products. Your desired look influences the best format and finish for you.
Longevity and Wear
Long-lasting formulas, especially waterproof or smudge-proof ones, are better suited for all-day wear or active routines. The tarte Fake Awake excels here, offering 8 hours of waterproof brightness. Conversely, creams and gels may need touch-ups but typically blend more seamlessly. Balance your need for durability against ease of application and removal.
Skin Compatibility and Ingredients
If you have sensitive skin or prefer clean beauty, look for vegan, gluten-free, and dermatologist-tested options like the Lune+Aster or tarte Fake Awake. Nourishing ingredients such as oils in the Thrive stick can also benefit dry or sensitive eyes. Always check ingredients if you have allergies or sensitivities to ensure your chosen highlighter enhances rather than irritates.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best type of eye highlighter for everyday use?
The baked gelato or stick highlighters, such as the Laura Geller Gilded Honey or Thrive Causemetics, tend to offer a natural, luminous glow that is easy to blend and wearable for daily routines. They provide enough brightness without looking overdone, making them perfect for casual or professional settings.
How do I choose between a pencil and a cream highlighter?
Pencil highlighters like the tarte Fake Awake are ideal for precise application in specific areas, especially for brightening the waterline or inner corners. Creams or gels, like the Thrive stick, offer a more blended, radiant finish and can be used on multiple parts of the face or eyes. Your preference for control versus ease of blending influences this choice.
Are waterproof highlighters worth it?
Absolutely, especially if you need your highlighter to stay put through sweat, tears, or long days. Waterproof formulas like tarte Fake Awake ensure brightness remains intact without smudging or fading, which is a key advantage for active lifestyles or humid climates.
Can I use these highlighters on my cheeks or lips?
Many of these products, like the Thrive Causemetics stick, are multi-use and designed to work on eyes, cheeks, and lips. However, it’s important to check each product’s specifications and ingredients to ensure compatibility. Some highlighters, especially those with shimmer finishes, can add a radiant touch to cheeks, but not all are suitable for lips.
How do I prevent highlighters from emphasizing fine lines?
For a smooth, youthful appearance, apply a moisturizer or primer before highlighter, and use a light hand when blending. Cream or gel formulas tend to be more forgiving and less likely to settle into lines compared to powders or shimmer-heavy products. Choosing a product with a satin or subtle shimmer finish can also help avoid emphasizing imperfections.
Conclusion
For those seeking a natural glow suitable for everyday wear, the Laura Geller Baked Gelato Swirl is a gentle, long-lasting option. If you prefer quick, precise highlighting or brightening, the Lune+Aster Pencil is perfect. Active users or those needing all-day waterproof wear will find the tarte Fake Awake to be the best fit. Meanwhile, the Thrive Causemetics stick suits anyone looking for a multi-purpose, nourishing highlighter with a soft shimmer. Your choice should align with your routine, preferred finish, and specific skin needs.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
